Debate: Should the U.S. Missionaries Get Punished For Kidnapping?

QUESTION: Should the U.S. Missionaries Get Punished For Kidnapping?

The Situation: Ten U.S. missionaries have been detained for attempting to take/smuggle 33 Haitian children, without proper documentation, out of the country. They are currently charged with kidnapping children and criminal association. The kidnappers have said that they were only trying to help the children since Haiti is currently in bad conditions. Some of the parents (of the children) said they had "willingly given their children over to the Americans, who promised them a better life and who said they could see their children whenever they wanted to." (Source: CNN)

Write either yes or no and give an explanation for your answer.

TIPS/IDEAS TO GET YOU STARTED:
*The intentions of the missionaries.
*Current conditions of Haiti.
*Should their religion be used as an excuse.
*Not having the proper documentations.

RULES FOR THIS DEBATE:
Cussing, bashing others comments and changing the subject is not allowed. Try to keep it clean.

---------------------------------------------------

EXTRA:
I love reading comments, whether it be on this site or another. I personally love reading comments on news sites such as CNN, MSNBC, etc. It's interesting to see the different responses people leave on these post. Some are interesting while others are kind of umm...well yeah.

***************

"If these fanatics really wanted to help the children, they would have given their parents money instead of taking advantage of their poverty to steal their children. I hope they are found guilty. There is only one thing worse than kidnapping children, and that is kidnapping children in the name of God. How arrogant, cruel, and hateful to leave the children's parents in poverty while breaking their hearts, and the children's hearts by using that as an excuse to steal their children. It is sickening."

*****************

"Drop a million condoms on Hatai from a cargo plane!! Message for all Hatains - wear a condom.!!!"

******************

"Yeah they kidnapped them because it's God's will. Hiding behind God after committing a crime is simply getting old."

******************

"I wish stupidity was a crime... but kidnapping and human trafficking will have to suffice..."

******************

"Yea they shoulda left them little kids there to die. Some people you just cant help.

---Exactly. Let nature take its course.

------WOW! I can't believe a comment like that, that is pretty harsh!

---------Harsh? What's so wrong with letting people in poverty die? What's wrong with trying to get rid of problem that has plagued humanity for centuries? Let them die."

********************

"The missionaries were obviously stupid to try this without papers etc. but for them to be tried as if it were normal conditions is a travesty. Like someone else correctly pointed out was there correct paper work for dumping truck loads of bodies unceremoniously into a pit? There are probably people practicing medicine w/o a license BUT they are all there helping. Anyone who says "the law is the law" doesn't
really understand the circumstances during such a disaster. Why don't the police start fining people there for dumping rubble in the street because the law is the law!"

*********************

"I'm trying to figure out what they planned to do with these children. No paperwork means no legal adoptions. Sneaking across the border to DR where there was no orphanage waiting?

Has anyone figured out what these people were planning to do with the kids? Why were they happy to get any children they could get their hands on, and not those most in need... like the homeless? Were they planning on bringing these kids back and selling in illegal adoptions for profit? All in the name of god?"

**********************

"There is always two side of a story. There is a good side and a bad side. The winner of this case will just have to be the most convincing. Life is nothing but a lot of risk and taking chances. Some good, some bad. The question is, "Who gets away with it?"."